Step into an alternate reality within the world of Red Dead Redemption 2, where Hosea Matthews, the Van der Linde gang's moral compass, survives the game's tumultuous events. Join us as we explore the intriguing 'what if' scenario: How would Hosea's survival have shaped the gang's fate?

Discover the pivotal role Hosea played in keeping Dutch in check and how his continued existence could have altered Dutch's decisions, the gang's direction, and Arthur Morgan's personal journey. Could Hosea have prevented the gang's tragic downfall, or was their fate sealed from the start?

We'll dissect key moments and pivotal events to unravel the complex web of possibilities, exploring both sides of the argument. Would Hosea's survival have led to a brighter future, or would it have plunged the gang into even darker depths?

Join the debate and share your thoughts in the comments below. And if you enjoy exploring alternate narratives and untold stories, be sure to subscribe! Don't miss this captivating exploration of Hosea's pivotal role in Red Dead Redemption 2!