Professional identity defines what it means to be a nurse, encompassing values like courage, integrity, and advocacy. But what happens when a devastating mistake challenges those very values? The case of RaDonda Vaught, a nurse who admitted a fatal medication error, shines a light on this paradox. Despite enduring public scrutiny and losing her license, Vaught consistently acted with accountability and remorse, exemplifying the importance of professional identity even in the face of tragedy. Join us for a crucial conversation with RaDonda as we delve into her story and explore how to foster a more forgiving and supportive environment for nurses.