Scott Carney's False Narrative on Wim Hof Finally exposed and scientifically debunked
Dominique Stulens Dominique Stulens
552 subscribers
15,167 views
484

 Published On Premiered Oct 1, 2023

INTRODUCTION | SUMMARY
Within the first 2 minutes, the latest study on "shallow water blackout" (2023) proves that Wim Hof's teachings in the water are 100% scientifically safe and that Scott Carneys accusation, "Wim Hof teaches deadly practices in the water" is just a wild, personal, false story.
After Scott Carney was fiercely criticized on accusing Wim Hof, he fabricated a false narrative in 4 steps with a “montage of videos", disregarding science ánd journalism integrity. The summary gives you a glimpse of the whole story. Watch it fully, or scroll through the content to see it in detail.

PART I - SCIENCE : based on science, Scott Carneys "scientific investigation" and Wim Hofs Ice water challenge are investigated in the depth. The science undeniably proves the safety of Wims teachings.
It also REVEALS Scott Carneys 'lack of scientific investigation" and his multiple 'wrong scientific assumptions" on “hyperventilation", “prolonged breath-holding". It also shows how his “recipe of Shallow Water Blackout" lacks the most important ingredient. No, Scotts Scientific investigation was not very well this time.

PART II : WIM HOF ORIGINAL FOOTAGE : we compare Wim Hofs original footage to the deliberate misrepresentations of Scott's "montage of videos". This comparison EXPOSES Scott Carneys lack of journalism integrity with regard to his Wim Hof- videos, his accusations and condescending behavior. The original footage shows how Scott Carney puts his credibility and integrity as a journalist on the line in order to defend his false narrative at all cost.

PART III : CONCLUSIONS & MOTIVATION. Based on science and on Wim Hofs original footage, final conclusions are made and we figure out WHY Scott Carney attacked Wim Hof so viciously, without the science to back it up and by deliberately misrepresenting Wim Hofs original footage.

In PART III, I also highlight my personal motivation to make this video: JUSTICE

--------------------------------

00:00 INTRODUCTION | SUMMARY

PART I : SCOTT CARNEYS LACK OF SCIENTIFIC INVESTIGATION?

18:18 Scott Carneys deliberate conflation of 2 WHM Breathing exercises
24:33 Scott Carney oversymplifies the science on "shallow water blackout"
25:37 Science on Shallow Water Blackout
28:09 Pathophysiology of “Shallow Water Blackout”
30:43 Pathophysyology of “Autonomic Conflict”
33:22 Wim Hof Method Satefy (contra-indications, safety videos, Wim Hof Academy)
38:01 Learning the Wim Hof Method through unofficial Channels
39:21 Scott Carneys wrong scientific assumptions
40:14 Intensity of Hyperventilation and CO2 levels
42:49 Different levels of hypocapnia or low CO2 levels
43:58 Conscious Breathing and CO2 levels
45:02 Study on Voluntary Hyperventilation 2022
47:13 Why is Conscious breathing not the same as hyperventilation?
49:55 Scientific study 2023 : Hyperventilation & a full inhale and head immersion in cold water: Wim Hofs teachings are scientifically safe.
57:34 Prevention of Shallow Water blackout
1:00:24 Scientific conclusions on Scott Carneys investigation and Wim Hofs teachings

1:02:27 PART II : SCOTT CARNEYS & JOURNALISM INTEGRITY?

1:04:52 Journalism and telling the truth
1:06:26 Scott Carney "montage of videos"
1:07:19 Scott Carneys misrepresentations of Wim Hofs Instructions: week 8 -10 week course
1:20:01 Original footage of Wim Hofs real instructions: week 8 - ten week course
1:24:30 Scott Carney STRANGE review of Wim Hof week 8 Icewater Training
1:31:29 Scott Carney "analysis" of Wim Hofs Baptism Poland 2023
1:34:37 Wim Hof original Footage on Freeze the Fear - BBC - 2022
1:38:49 Scott Carney version of Freeze the Fear - Wim Hof - BBC 2022
1:44:42 Conclusion Scott Carney Misrepresentations in his “Montage of videos’

PART III - CONCLUSIONS AND MOTIVATION

1:45:13 Conclusions - Wim Hofs Icewater challenge is scientifically safe
1:45:44 Wim Hofs Icewater challenge is a limited breath hold exercise
1:46:08 Wim Hofs Conscious Breathing is not hyperventilation
1:47:00 Awareness and prevention of shallow water blackout
1:48:02 Scott Carney lack of Scientific investigation
1:49:32 Scott Carney lack of journalism integrity
1:50:51 Scott Carneys motivations? Resentment and/or Fear?
1:54:12 True Investigation
1:56:24 Was Scott Carney obsessed with Wim Hof?
1:57:35 Practice the Wim Hof Method safely and enjoy it
1:58:45 My personal motivation to make this video
2:03:27 One more thing …

----------------------------
Youtube videos:

Wim Hof Safety information :    • Wim Hof Method | Safety Information  

Wim Hof Breathing tutorial :    • Wim Hof breathing tutorial by Wim Hof  

Prof Mike Shattock - "Autonomic conflict a different way to die?" :    • Prof Mike Shattock - "Autonomic confl...  

---------------------------
Scientific references :

https://dominiquestulens.be/wp-conten...

--------------------------
Background music :    • I Believe [Original Mix] - Imperss | ...  

THANK YOU!

show more

Share/Embed